If we acknowledge God as our Father, is it even possible to suffer anxiety? Would trust not just take over and eliminate all tendency to worry? St. Paul seems to exhort the early Christians to a lack of worry.
Have no anxiety at all, but in everything, by prayer and petition, with thanksgiving, make your requests known to God. Then the peace of God that surpasses all understanding will guard your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus (Philippians 4:6-7).
Is the human experience of anxiety a failure to fulfill this command? The very thought may be anxiety-provoking for some people. Don’t worry, this is not the case.
Christian hope does not mean that we will never experience anxiety. Even when anxiety is present, we can continue to entrust ourselves to God. Faith doesn’t eliminate our fears, but gives us a way to face them.
Our Father
The Our Father is such a powerful prayer. It expresses our complete and total dependence on God. One of the great revelations of Jesus Christ is that we can call God “Abba - Father.” When suffering in the Garden of Gethsemane, Jesus prayed to his Father using this word. It expresses filial trust. We are allowed to direct ourselves to God as Father because Jesus taught us to pray thus in the Our Father. We might be led to believe that this prayer is so powerful that it should bring us back to our true center and help us overcome any mental struggles we might be experiencing.
We could be tempted to think that this means that praying the Our Father should take away all anxiety that we might experience. First of all, we have to understand the nature of anxiety. Anxiety has both a mental and physical aspect. When we experience anxiety, our bodies respond to a perceived threat, even if it is only imagined or not objectively present. It is not merely “in our mind,” so this can already give us a clue that it cannot always be resolved purely through a good spiritual practice.
The prayer of faith consists not only in saying, “Lord, Lord,” but in disposing the heart to do the will of the Father. Jesus calls his disciples to bring into their prayer this concern for cooperating with the divine plan (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2611).
Sometimes, even if we are trying to dispose ourselves to serve God more perfectly, we may be hindered by obstacles due to our personal circumstances or obstacles in our environment.
Aligning our Wills to God’s Will
Trying to align our wills to God’s Will is definitely a good thing, and can often help to reduce anxiety. On its own, however, it may often not be enough. This is where good therapy can be helpful, giving the person strategies for how to deal with anxiety on a practical level. We can know and accept on a theoretical level that we want our hearts to be disposed to God, but practically speaking, we still suffer a lot of resistance.
Prayer and therapy are not competing strategies to deal with anxiety. A person of faith should bring all problems to prayer, but this does not preclude professional guidance when that is necessary or helpful.
Unity of Body and Soul
The Church has always emphasized that as human beings we are body and soul (cf. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 362-365).
The human person, created in the image of God, is a being at once corporeal and spiritual (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 362).
The unity of body and soul is so profound that we cannot take care of the soul completely without giving any consideration to the body. Taking mental health seriously is not a lack of consideration of spiritual life. It may even be necessary or at least beneficial for our spiritual lives.
Complicating Our Prayer
If we do not take care of the mental health issues we are dealing with, we might even complicate our prayer lives. Or a misguided prayer routine could exacerbate our mental health issues. If we assume that more prayer is automatically going to get rid of our anxiety, we might be setting ourselves up for scrupulosity.
We have to avoid two extremes: over-spiritualizing mental health problems and extreme rationalism that ignores the existence of the spiritual life. Some schools of psychology deny the existence of the soul and reduce everything to chemical processes within the brain. Some spiritualities deny the real help that mental health professionals can provide to an individual dealing with anxiety.
We should not look at the absence of mental health struggles as a sign of a healthy prayer life. While probably not anxiety, we see Jesus suffer anguish in the Garden of Gethsemane. When we feel anxious, we can unite ourselves to Jesus as he suffers, thinking of the tremendous suffering he is about to undergo.
Trusting God does not mean we will never experience fear. Rather, even in our fear, we know we can turn to our Heavenly Father.



Thank you, Fr. Sheehy, this was a very helpful article. It helped me to understand how anxiety and my faith are interconnected.
Father Nicholas, would you please pray for my intention as it relates very much to this post? I am working on a book proposal that addresses these themes of fear, anxiety, and our relationship with the Father. I am praying that God's will be done as I surrender the writing and prepare to pitch the book idea. Thanks.